2007 House Bill 2079: Concerning use of agency shop fees.
Introduced by Rep. Joe McDermott (D) on February 7, 2007
To modify current law that prohibits labor organizations from using shop fees from non-members for political campaigns. This bill would allow shop fees to be used for political campaigns as long as the labor organization has sufficient funds from other sources. The bill has an emergency clause, which makes its take effect immediately. See companion SB 5921.
Official Text and Analysis.
Referred to the House State Government & Tribal Affairs Committee on February 7, 2007
Referred to the House Rules Committee on February 23, 2007
Amendment offered by Rep. Bruce Chandler (Yakima) (R) on March 9, 2007
To strike the underlying bill. The amendment provides
legislative findings that intend to specify limits on the use
of agency shop fees; recognize constitutional limits on the
ability of the legislature to authorize a compelled payment for
collective bargaining services and that the legislature must
protect speech over labor organization convenience; recognize
that many labor organizations operate without use of mandatory
dues and that mandatory dues are not necessary for the
interests and rights of labor organizations; and that generally
accepted accounting principles consider commingled funds to be
from all sources and only a complete refund of agency fees
would satisfy the requirements of the Citizen's Initiative
Measure No. 134.
Allows labor organizations to use any fund or account from
which payments or expenditures are made, and where agency shop
fees are commingled, to make political campaign contributions
if all agency shops fees collected in the twelve months prior
to the contribution have been refunded in full to those who did
not affirmatively authorize such use.
Provides definitions for: "agency shop fees"; "affirmatively
authorized"; "use of agency shop fees"; and "expenditures to
influence an election".
The amendment failed by voice vote in the House on March 9, 2007
Amendment offered by Rep. Cary Condotta (East Wenatchee) (R) on March 9, 2007
To strike the underlying bill. Amends RCW 28B.52.045
regarding collective bargaining agreements in higher education,
RCW 41.56.122 regarding public employment collective bargaining
agreements, RCW 41.76.045 regarding exclusive bargaining
representation for public employees at 4-years institutions,
RCW 41.59.100 regarding collection of agency shop fees, RCW
41.80.100 regarding negotiation and ratification of collective
bargaining agreements for state employees, and RCW 47.64.160
regarding collective bargaining for marine employees so that
there is nothing in these sections to obligate employers to
withhold funds for PACs and to require pro rata accounting for
actual collective bargaining and labor representation costs.
Prohibits the inclusion of a union security provision in a
collective bargaining agreement unless the labor organization
provides each employee with annual written notice informing the
employee:
• on the right to decline membership and the process for
paying only a representation fee;
• that each employee has a right of nonassociation with the
organization; and
• about specific financial information of the exclusive
bargaining unit.
The labor organization must also permit all members of the
bargaining unit equal representation and may not use agency
shop fees for political campaign contributions without
affirmative authorization.
The amendment failed by voice vote in the House on March 9, 2007
Amendment offered by Rep. Mike Armstrong, (R-Wenatchee) (R) on March 9, 2007
To allow labor organization general treasury funds to be used
for political contributions and expenditures if nonmembers have
been provided either a pro-rata or actual rebate of the amount
of money not used for collective bargaining or other purposes
necessary to the labor process; removes the emergency clause.
The amendment failed by voice vote in the House on March 9, 2007
Amendment offered by Rep. Bruce Chandler (Yakima) (R) on March 9, 2007
To prohibit labor organizations from using any funds for
political contributions when such funds are commingled with
agency shop fees; removes language from original bill defining
when an agency does not use agency shop fees; removes the
emergency clause.
Amendment offered by Rep. Joel Kretz (Ferry) (R) on March 9, 2007
To remove the emergency clause.
Amendment offered by Rep. Bruce Chandler (Yakima) (R) on March 9, 2007
To add definitions of "agency shop fees", "use of agency
shop fees", "expenditures to influence and election", "to
operate a political committee", and "affirmatively authorized";
removes language from original bill defining when an agency
does not use agency shop fees; removes the emergency clause.
The amendment failed by voice vote in the House on March 9, 2007
Amendment offered by Rep. Bruce Chandler (Yakima) (R) on March 9, 2007
To strike the underlying bill. Prohibits labor
organizations from transferring or contributing agency shop
fees to an affiliated organization that makes political
campaign contributions and expenditures.
The amendment failed by voice vote in the House on March 9, 2007
Amendment offered by Rep. Mike Armstrong, (R-Wenatchee) (R) on March 9, 2007
To require labor organizations to allocate the cost of
chargeable activities equally among members and nonmembers on
a per employee basis so that the agency shop fees are not
subsidizing the nonchargeable activities of the labor
organization. Removes the emergency clause.
The amendment failed by voice vote in the House on March 9, 2007
Amendment offered by Rep. Bruce Chandler (Yakima) (R) on March 9, 2007
To assure that agency shop fees may not exceed a pro
rata share of expenditures for purposes germane to the
collective bargaining process, to contract administration, or
to pursuing matters affecting wages, hours, and other
conditions of employment. Determination of the share of the
fee shall be documented for the nonmember using historical
data.
If this is adopted, RCW 42.17.760 becomes moot for public
employee labor.
The amendment failed by voice vote in the House on March 9, 2007
Amendment offered by Rep. Bill Hinkle, (R-Cle Elum) (R) on March 9, 2007
To require the public disclosure commission to implement
a reporting mechanism for the political contributions of labor
organizations; the information provided by the labor
organization must include information on total expenditures
made by the labor organization, information regarding revenue
sources and amount received from each revenue source including
member dues and agency shop fees, and specific information
regarding political campaign contributions; the public
disclosure commission must provide an annual report from this
information; removes the emergency clause.
The amendment failed by voice vote in the House on March 9, 2007
Amendment offered by Rep. Bruce Chandler (Yakima) (R) on March 9, 2007
To require that to use a fund or account where agency
shop fees are commingled, the labor organizations must have
provided nonmembers with a rebate of agency shop fees that is
equal to a pro-rata share of the average of the amount spent in
contributions or expenditures to influence an election or to
operate a political committee over the preceding three reported
years plus a 3 percent cushion; removes language from original
bill defining when an agency does not use agency shop fees;
removes the emergency clause.
The amendment failed by voice vote in the House on March 9, 2007
Amendment offered by Rep. Mike Armstrong, (R-Wenatchee) (R) on March 9, 2007
To change references about a labor organization's
general treasury fund to refer to any fund or account where
agency shop fees are commingled. Requires labor organizations
to provide nonmembers with written notice as to its compliance
with the statutory requirements for use of agency shop fees.
Written notice must include the text of the statute, an
explanation that the individual is receiving the notice because
he or she is a nonmember, and a financial accounting of the
labor organization for the three previous fiscal years that
includes revenue from member dues and agency shop fees and
expenditures for chargeable and nonchargeable activities.
Included with the written notice must be a card the nonmember
can sign and return to the labor organization to obtain a
refund of fees not spent on chargeable activities. Removes the
emergency clause.
Amendment offered by Rep. Jay Rodne (North Bend) (R) on March 9, 2007
To provide nonmembers a with a legal cause of action if
a labor organization spends his or her agency shop fees in
violation of the affirmative authorization requirement of this
statute; in the event of a judgment against the labor
organization, the court may impose a $25,000 civil penalty;
prohibits labor organizations from enforcing a union security
agreement if it has been found in violation of the statute;
removes language defining when an agency does not use agency
shop fees; removes the emergency clause.
The amendment failed by voice vote in the House on March 9, 2007
Amendment offered by Rep. Jim Dunn, (R-Vancouver) (R) on March 9, 2007
To provide that for teachers covered by a union security
provision and who assert a right of nonassociation based on a
bona fide personally held religious belief or on the tenets or
teachings of a church or religious body of which such employee
is a member, the employee must pay an amount of money
equivalent to regular dues and fees to any nonreligious charity
or charitable organization that is registered with the
secretary without mutual agreement with the bargaining
representative.
The amendment failed by voice vote in the House on March 9, 2007
Received in the Senate on March 12, 2007
Referred to the Senate Labor, Commerce, Research and Development Committee on March 12, 2007
Referred to the Senate Rules Committee on March 30, 2007
Amendment offered by Sen. Don Benton (Vancouver) (R) on April 13, 2007
To provide that teachers covered by a union security
provision who assert a right of nonassociation based on a bona fide
personally held religious belief or on the tenets or teachings of
a church or religious body of which such employee is a member, the
employee may pay an amount of money equivalent to regular dues and
fees to any non-religious charitable organization in lieu of union
dues.
Amendment offered by Sen. Jim Clements (R) on April 13, 2007
To provide nonmembers a with a legal cause of action if a
labor organization spends his or her agency shop fees in violation
of the affirmative authorization requirement of this statute; in
the event of a judgment against the labor organization, the court
may impose a $25,000 civil penalty; removes the emergency clause.
The amendment failed by voice vote in the Senate on April 13, 2007
Amendment offered by Sen. Jim Clements (R) on April 13, 2007
To amend statutes regarding collective bargaining agreements
to require pro rata accounting for actual collective bargaining and
labor representation costs.
Prohibits the inclusion of a union security provision in a
collective bargaining agreement unless the labor organization
provides each employee with annual written notice informing the
employee or certain rights.
The labor organization must also permit all members of the
bargaining unit equal representation and may not use agency shop
fees for political campaign contributions without affirmative
authorization.
The amendment failed by voice vote in the Senate on April 13, 2007
Amendment offered by Sen. Janéa Holmquist Newbry (Moses Lake) (R) on April 13, 2007
To implement the directive of the superior court by requiring
that to use a fund or account where agency shop fees are
commingled, the labor organization must have provided nonmembers
with a rebate of agency shop fees that is equal to a pro-rata share
of the average of the amount spent in contributions or expenditures
to influence an election or to operate a political committee over
the preceding three reported years plus a 3 % cushion; removes
language from original bill defining when an agency does not use
agency shop fees; removes the emergency clause.
The amendment failed by voice vote in the Senate on April 13, 2007
Amendment offered by Sen. Janéa Holmquist Newbry (Moses Lake) (R) on April 13, 2007
To clarify the legislative findings that intend to
specify limits on the use of agency shop fees. Allows labor
organizations to use any fund or account from which payments or
expenditures are made, and where agency shop fees are commingled,
to make political campaign contributions, but only if all agency
shop fees collected in the twelve months prior to the contribution
have been refunded in full to those who did not affirmatively
authorize such use.
Provides definitions for: "agency shop fees"; "affirmatively
authorized"; "use of agency shop fees"; and "expenditures to
influence an election".
The amendment failed by voice vote in the Senate on April 13, 2007
Amendment offered by Sen. Janéa Holmquist Newbry (Moses Lake) (R) on April 13, 2007
To require an affirmative authorization for political
expenditures of nonmember fees, and defines "agency shop fees" and
"affirmatively authorized".
The amendment failed by voice vote in the Senate on April 13, 2007
Amendment offered by Sen. Jim Honeyford (Grandview) (R) on April 13, 2007
To remove the emergency clause.
The amendment failed by voice vote in the Senate on April 13, 2007
Amendment offered by Sen. Jim Honeyford (Grandview) (R) on April 13, 2007
To prohibit labor organizations from using any funds for
political contributions when such funds are commingled with agency
shop fees. Removes emergency clause.
The amendment failed by voice vote in the Senate on April 13, 2007
Amendment offered by Sen. Mark Schoesler (Ritzville) (R) on April 13, 2007
To remove the emergency clause and adds a referendum clause.
Signed by Gov. Christine Gregoire on May 11, 2007